Oct 01, 2012 alvin plantingas where the conflict really lies. Alvin carl plantinga born 1932 is an american analytic philosopher who works primarily in the fields of philosophy of religion, epistemology particularly on issues involving epistemic justification, and logic. The christian philosopher alvin plantinga has tried to make the argument that evolution combined with naturalism would lead us to believe that evolution would favor false beliefs over accurate beliefs and that if naturalism were true, we wouldnt expect our cognitive. I was fortunate to spend some time with him recently and talked about his book and how he thinks about this supposed conflict. Plantingas book is a semipopular treatment of the conflicts, real or perceived. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of. The argument was first proposed by alvin plantinga in 1993 and raises issues of interest to epistemologists, philosophers of mind, evolutionary biologists, and. Jan 02, 2019 plantinga argues that the conflict between science and theistic religion is superficial, and that at a deeper level they are in fact compatible. His theme in this short book is that the conflict between science and theistic.
Their belief that evolution rules out the existence of god including a god. Plantinga construed evolutionary naturalism as the conjunction of the idea that human cognitive faculties arose through evolutionary mechanisms, and naturalism which he equated to atheism. Plantinga on where the conflict really lies evolution news. Find evolutionary psychology textbooks at up to 90% off. Plantinga concludes the book by explaining that there is no significant conflict between science and religion rather there exists great concord, but that the conflict really lies between naturalism and evolution. Evolutionary psychology is an approach that views human nature as the product of a universal set of evolved psychological adaptations to recurring problems in the ancestral environment. Alvin carl plantinga born 1932 is an american analytic philosopher who works primarily in the fields of philosophy of religion, epistemology particularly on issues involving epistemic justification, and logic from 1963 to 1982, plantinga taught at calvin university before accepting an appointment as the john a. Naturalism defeated essays on plantingas evolutionary.
Plantinga s thesis is that there is a superficial conflict but deep concord between science and theistic religion, but superficial concord and deep conflict between science and naturalism. Within the field of evolutionary science, critics admit that organisms can be. Likewise, he observes that some conclusions of modern biblical criticism seem to be a threat to christian belief. In part ii, superficial conflict, he deals with evolutionary psychology and biblical criticism. This chapter argues that there is superficial conflict but deep concord between science and theistic belief, and superficial concord and deep conflict between science and naturalism.
Most of his experience is in adult and post secondary education. The book examines where this conflict is supposed to existevolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religionas well as. If you want to have the broadest overview of evolutionary psychology, this your book. Plantingas control of language is unmatched, his reasoning and writing of the utmost quality and clarity. In this, the first book to address the ongoing debate, plantinga presents his influential thesis and responds to critiques by distinguished. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to existevolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as. Science, religion, and naturalism by plantinga, alvin isbn. May 10, 20 millions of years of evolutionary programming are not easily shaked off. Nov 16, 2011 plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist.
In the actual world i am writing up this blog post, but i could have decid. Alvin plantinga on evolutionary psychology and christian. As the above quotation suggests, one shouldnt look to this book for evenhanded and thoughtful commentary. Dec 09, 2011 plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. Plantinga tried to throw doubt on this conjunction with a preliminary argument that the conjunction is probably false, and a main argument that it is selfdefeating. An introduction to the thought of alvin plantinga crossway. Alvin plantinga christian analytic philosopher bishops. Alvin plantingas essay games scientists play, as published in the book. Plantingas tiger and other stupid shit soon after, the christian presuppositionalist josh sommer was having none of that. Massimo pigliucci, a philosopher at the city university of new york. The last twenty years has seen a cottage industry of books on this divide, but with little consensus emerging.
In the closing chapter of warrant and proper function alvin plantinga claims that the combination of naturalism according to which there is no god as conceived of in traditional theism and evolutionary theory according to which our cognitive capabilities are the products of blind processes. Plantinga s argument has been criticized in detail from the viewpoints of natural sciences and philosophy of science. Naturalism defeated essays on plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. According to plantinga the crucial philosophical question to be asked concerning evolutionary psychology and especially the hbc is whether these provide defeaters for christian belief. On plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Plantinga, as a respected philosopher, has added a much needed contribution to this literature.
Obrien professor of philosophy emeritus at the university of notre dame, and the inaugural holder of the jellema chair in philosophy at calvin college plantinga is widely known for his work in philosophy of religion, epistemology, metaphysics and christian apologetics. Science, religion, and naturalism wcrl is a valuable contribution to the vast current literature devoted to the subject of whether science and religion are in irreconcilable conflict. Here is how he formulates the argument in his recent where the conflict really lies oxford university press, 2011, pp. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to existevolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. Obrien professor of philosophy at the university of notre dame. Evolutionary argument against naturalism in plantinga s evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan for short12, he attempts to show that to combine naturalism and evolution is selfdefeating, because, under these assumptions, the probability that humans have reliable cognitive faculties is low or inscrutable.
As is typically done, we might think of a possible world as a complete way that things might have been. He spent nineteen years as a professor at calvin college, then eighteen years at the university of notre dame, and returned to calvin college in 2010. Alvin plantingas new book on god and science the new york. Alvin plantinga, who has led a movement of unapologetically christian. Plantinga s forthcoming book on science, religion, and naturalism alvin plantinga has a book thats due out in september with oxford university press. The evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan is a philosophical argument asserting a problem with believing both evolution and philosophical naturalism simultaneously. Why the evidence of evolution reveals a universe without design.
So he wrote three whole articles trying to argue against me. Covering a range of topics, from the evolution of language, theory of mind, and the mentality of apes, through to psychological disorders, human mating strategies and relationship processes, this volume makes a. From 1963 to 1982, plantinga taught at calvin college before accepting an appointment as the john a. Reassessing plantingas ontological argument for god. It might be true, but it cannot be rational to affirm it as such. Alvin plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Alvin plantingas new book on god and science the new. A better story, he suggests, would be saint augustines own. Plantinga also writes wtcrl, 316 that the problem of reliable cognitive faculties under naturalistic evolution has appeared troubling to atheists as well. Eaan is a curious little argument that some have dismissed as a resurgent example of scholastic theology. Plantinga s control of language is unmatched, his reasoning and writing of the utmost quality and clarity. Reviewers thoughts where the conflict really lies was a challenging but rewarding read.
Choose from used and new textbooks or get instant access with etextbooks and digital materials. Books about evolutionary psychology written for a general audience. Plantinga, as a top philosopher but also a proponent of the rationality of religious belief, has a unique. Science, religion, and naturalism alvin plantinga addresses philosophically the perennial question of the conflict between science and religion.
In answering this he offers a detailed epistemological analysis of defeat. As is typical for christian apologists especially presuppositionalists, his. Alvin carl plantinga born in ann arbor, michigan, the first of four sons of cornelius a. Nietzsche, nagel, stroud, churchland, and darwin, nontheists all, seem to concur. Where the conflict really lies audiobook by alvin plantinga. Sep 20, 2017 you remember a while back when i dared to call alvin plantinga a terrible philosopher spewing pseudoscience. This, plantinga argued, epistemically defeats the belief that naturalistic evolution is true and that ascribing truth to naturalism and evolution is internally dubious or inconsistent. Given that naturalism is at least a quasireligion, there is indeed a sciencereligion conflict, all right, but it is not between science and theistic religion. Apr 03, 2015 plantingas argument is intended to show that evolutionary naturalism cannot be rationally affirmed. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist. Plantingas book is a semipopular treatment of the conflicts, real or.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. The god delusion, however, contains little science. Evolutionary naturalism, theism, and skepticism about the external world 2000 j. Not surprisingly, plantinga spends a good bit of time dealing with biological evolution in part i of the book, alleged conflict. Plantinga writing almost a century and a half after darwin has no such excuse, and we are right in rejecting his eaan as a clever but inevitably flawed example of neoscholasticism. Plantinga s book is a semipopular treatment of the conflicts, real or perceived, between science and religion, broadly construed. Philosophy news interview with alvin plantinga on where. Almost a decade ago, alvin plantinga articulated his bold and controversial evolutionary argument against naturalism. As the son of a philosophy and psychology professor, plantinga evidenced a knack for and interest in philosophy early on.
The future of an illusion the standard edition complete psychological. Evolutionary psychology seems to pose a greater threat to christian belief, in that it claims to explain morality, altruism and religious belief in ways that effectively explain them away. Discover the best evolutionary psychology in best sellers. He examines where this conflict is typically believed to exist, namely in evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, and scientific study of religion.
Lesser mortals like me cant claim to fully understand everything alvin plantinga writes in books like where the conflict really lies. Where the conflict really lies alvin plantinga oxford. His book, where the conflict really lies, is sure to generate a lot of discussion and be the subject of much debate. For plantinga, evolution is a mere story or myth that attempts to account for the apparent connections among life forms. Why plantingas tiger is pseudoscience richard carrier. The purpose of evolutionary psychology is to identify evolved. In fact the proportion of insult, ridicule, mockery, spleen, and vitriol is astounding. Plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Pdf evolutionary psychology download full pdf book. Alvin plantinga on evolutionary psychology and christian belief. The new science of evolutionary psychology by robert wright, the b.
Plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism the. God implanted seeds, potentialities of various kinds in the world, so that the various kinds of creatures would later arise, although not by way of. Albeit designed as a textbook for graduate students, its equally good for the general public. Alvin plantinga famously defends a version of the ontological argument that makes use of the notion of possible worlds. Raised in the christian reformed church, he has theological roots in the dutch reformed tradition.
What are the problems with plantingas evolutionary. Sipper holds a phd in education, a masters of education, and a bachelors in english. Evolutionary argument against naturalism wikipedia. Evolutionary argument against naturalism oxford scholarship. This book is a longawaited major statement by a preeminent analytic philosopher, alvin plantinga, on one of our biggest debates the compatibility of science and religion.
What are the best books about evolutionary psychology. Plantinga has released a new book taking on the claim that religion and science are incompatible. This chapter, while heavy, is an extremely rewarding read, particularly for people with interests in evolutionary psychology, philosophy of religion, or both. The christian philosopher alvin plantinga has tried to make the argument that evolution combined with naturalism would lead us to believe that evolution would favor false beliefs over accurate beliefs and that if naturalism were true, we wouldnt expect our cognitive faculties to have evolved to accurately comprehend reality. Alvin plantinga project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. This intriguing line of argument raises issues of importance to epistemologists and to philosophers of mind, of religion, and of science. Apr 25, 2017 alvin plantinga was born in ann arbor, michigan. Review of alvin plantinga, where the conflict really lies. That belief, thereforethe conjunction of naturalism and evolution is one. He is known for his work in christian apologetics, epistemology, metaphysics, and the philosophy of religion, and in particular for applying the methods of analytic philosophy to defend orthodox christian beliefs. Find the top 100 most popular items in amazon books best sellers. Science, religion, and naturalism plantinga, alvin on.
This the leading textbook on evolutionary psychology. Because these disciplines are so broadly construed, the christian who is interested in apparent conflicts between science and biblical christianity will likely be somewhat disappointed in plantinga s treatment. Alvin plantinga, who has led a movement of unapologetically christian philosophers, argues that theism is compatible with science in his new book, where the conflict really lies. Portalpar alvin carl plantinga born 1932 is an american christian philosopher, currently the john a. Any theory which includes among its unknowns the reliability of human knowledge is going to fail plantinga s test. Score a book s total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book. Its philosophical dimension, a chapter of the cultures of creationism, ashgate, 2004.
474 989 1039 534 610 1360 1421 500 1062 567 1280 476 556 176 1078 1264 915 853 570 1449 941 850 1515 692 47 1162 692 1512 1398 1166 104 1074 264 1364 180 223 944 7